How to Make Frosting That’s Safe for Dogs (2024)

Decorating cookies is such a great activity during the holiday season, so why not include your dog in the fun? Using only dog-safe ingredients, you can mix up a tasty frosting topper for your pup’s treats. Not only will they absolutely love the flavor and texture, but you’ll make beautiful, photo-worthy creations that are full of holiday spirit.

There are actually many frosting recipes that are safe for dogs. We chose a simple one with plain Greek yogurt as the main ingredient because it contains healthy probiotics, plus tapioca starch, which helps the icing harden. You’ll get about one cup of frosting — and it only takes five minutes to prep!

How to Make Frosting That’s Safe for Dogs (1)

Ingredients:

  • 1/2 cup cooked tapioca starch (optional: sub cooked potato starch)
  • 1/2 cup plain Greek yogurt
  • 3 tablespoons water

Note: This recipe makes white frosting. To add color, we recommend puréeing dog-safe fruits or veggies like cranberries, strawberries, or parsley for natural red or green holiday colors. You can also buy natural food coloring from a health food store. Always check with your veterinarian to be sure it’s safe for your dog to have these ingredients.

How to Make Frosting That’s Safe for Dogs (2)

Directions:

    1. Place cooked tapioca (or potato) starch and yogurt in a small bowl and combine thoroughly.
    2. Mix in water, a tablespoon at a time, until you get the consistency of frosting.
    3. Get creative with your icing: Make a holiday decoration, write your dog’s name, or just dip BLUE Santa Snacks or BLUE Health Bars into the frosting.
    4. Place on wax paper to let the frosting harden, then serve immediately after. If preparing ahead of time, refrigerate treats before serving for birthdays, holidays, and other celebrations throughout the year. You may even want to leave a few for Santa’s reindeer.

    Have fun and enjoy celebrating with your best pal!

    How to Make Frosting That’s Safe for Dogs (3)

    How to Make Frosting That’s Safe for Dogs (2024)

    FAQs

    How to Make Frosting That’s Safe for Dogs? ›

    Place cooked tapioca (or potato) starch and yogurt in a small bowl and combine thoroughly. Mix in water, a tablespoon at a time, until you get the consistency of frosting. Get creative with your icing: Make a holiday decoration, write your dog's name, or just dip BLUE

    BLUE
    It all started with an Airedale named Blue.

    When their dog, Blue, was diagnosed with cancer, Bill Bishop and his sons sought out the best pet food possible for their boy. Unable to find a natural option with high-quality ingredients, they created their own.
    https://bluebuffalo.com › why-choose-blue › blue-story
    Santa Snacks or BLUE Health Bars into the frosting.

    What frosting is safe for dogs? ›

    Yogurt Frosting for Dogs

    Place yogurt and tapioca starch in a small bowl and thoroughly combine. Mix in milk a teaspoon at a time until consistency of frosting. Decorate or dip the dog treats. Place on wax paper and let dry.

    How do you make dog icing that doesn't crack? ›

    Directions
    1. In a small bowl add the cornstarch and honey.
    2. If using Peanut Butter, add it with the honey. The peanut butter gives the icing a smother consistency.
    3. Start adding water until desired consistency is achieved.
    4. Divide into portions and color with natural gel colors.
    5. Use to drizzle or spread on top of dog treats.

    What is the best hard icing for dog treats? ›

    Royal icing mix is the way to go, if you want to decorate your homemade dog treats the easy way! Using royal icing for your homemade dog treats has a number of advantages. Royal icing dries hard and stays hard, will not crack, and it won't melt, even when it's really hot outside.

    Can dogs have a small amount of frosting? ›

    Please don't. While accidently ingesting a small amount of frosting isn't a problem, frosting can cause tummy troubles for your pup. And in the long-term sugar poses various risks for dogs, including causing metabolic changes.

    What is dog treat icing made of? ›

    Place cooked tapioca (or potato) starch and yogurt in a small bowl and combine thoroughly. Mix in water, a tablespoon at a time, until you get the consistency of frosting.

    Is Betty Crocker icing safe for dogs? ›

    Sugar and artificial materials in Betty Crocker icing are mistaken for puppies in massive amounts. You need to avoid giving your dog this treat on an ordinary basis, especially if he is lactose illiberal. Consider the usage of dog-satisfactory frosting made especially for puppies.

    What food coloring is safe for dogs? ›

    Many spices and herbs can be used to colour your pup's food in a healthy way. You can use turmeric powder for yellows and oranges, spirulina* for greens, and beetroot powder* for pinks and reds.

    Why does my dog icing crack? ›

    So if you apply frosting, it dries to a hard shell overnight. It is now set. But, over the next day, the treat is still drying and thus, shrinking. So when the treat shrinks, but the frosting is now a hard shell, simple physics shows that the frosting will get a stress crack.

    Is it OK for dogs to eat icing? ›

    Feeding your dog sugary foods like frosting or icing in large quantities is not advisable because it can lead to various health issues, including obesity, dental problems, and, in extreme cases, pancreatitis.

    How to make high value dog treats at home? ›

    How to:
    1. Preheat your oven to 170°C.
    2. Dice the lamb liver.
    3. Puree the whole eggs with lamb liver in the food processor.
    4. Mix eggs and liver with the dry ingredients. ...
    5. Pour the mixture into the baking molds.
    6. Bake for 35 minutes or until golden brown and firm.
    7. Let the dog treats cool before it's time for dog training.
    Mar 30, 2024

    How do you make an ice lick for a dog? ›

    Assembly Instructions
    1. Place a few choice nibbles in the bottom of your bowl.
    2. Add your liquid to cover and freeze for 30 minutes.
    3. Repeat multiple times for multiple layers and flavors.
    4. Freeze for a few hours or until it's frozen solid.

    What is the best hard treat for dogs? ›

    Here are some features to be aware when shopping for dog toys for heavy chewers:
    • Size. ...
    • Ingredients and Materials. ...
    • Bully Sticks. ...
    • Tendon Chews. ...
    • Antlers. ...
    • Yak Chews. ...
    • ZILLA Rubber Dog Treat Toy. ...
    • Better Bone. This BetterBone Tough is our VERY favorite dog chew for aggressive chewers.
    Jun 21, 2023

    Is vanilla frosting safe for dogs? ›

    Icing or other dessert frostings are extremely high in sugar, which is not good for your dog. Although your dog will not die if they eat a bit of icing, it is not good for them because of the high sugar content.

    Is cream cheese frosting safe for dogs? ›

    Even a small amount of cream cheese can be bad for dogs with health concerns. Likewise, if your dog is lactose-intolerant, they should not eat cream cheese. When lactose-intolerant dogs eat cheese, they will likely experience upset stomach, diarrhea, or vomiting.

    Can dogs have cinnamon and icing? ›

    While cinnamon is not toxic to dogs, you should avoid sharing cinnamon baked goods with your canine companion. The reason for this is that these baked treats like cinnamon rolls, cinnamon bread, cinnamon toast crunch, cookies, and cakes usually contain many different ingredients that can be dangerous to dogs.

    Can dogs eat cool whip? ›

    Cool Whip uses high fructose corn syrup, which isn't toxic to dogs, but definitely isn't good for them. Sugar-free Cool Whip uses NutraSweet, which is derived from stevia, and is also non-toxic to dogs, but could upset their tummy in large quantities.

    Is royal icing OK for dogs? ›

    Can Meringue Powder or Human Royal Icing be used to decorate Dog Treats? No, No, No. Meringue Powder contains an ingredient called Cream of Tartar which is made from grapes, which are known to cause renal failure in dogs.

    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Article information

    Author: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

    Last Updated:

    Views: 5723

    Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

    Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

    Birthday: 2001-01-17

    Address: Suite 769 2454 Marsha Coves, Debbieton, MS 95002

    Phone: +813077629322

    Job: Real-Estate Executive

    Hobby: Archery, Metal detecting, Kitesurfing, Genealogy, Kitesurfing, Calligraphy, Roller skating

    Introduction: My name is Gov. Deandrea McKenzie, I am a spotless, clean, glamorous, sparkling, adventurous, nice, brainy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.