What can I substitute for cheddar cheese? (2023)

Here are the substituted cheeses for white cheddar that I think would perfectly replicate the taste of cheddar cheese.

  • #1. Edam. …
  • #2. Gouda. …
  • #3. Colby Cheese. …
  • #4. Brick Cheese. …
  • #5. Cantal Cheese. …
  • #6. Double Gloucester. …
  • #7. Mozzarella Cheese. …
  • What Goes Well With White Cheddar?

Consequently, What cheese is like pepper jack?

Top 10 Spices Used As Pepper Jack Cheese Substitutes

  • Cheddar Cheese. The first ingredient that we want to introduce is cheddar cheese, which is also the first answer for “What cheese is similar to Monterey Jack?”. …
  • Swiss Cheese. …
  • Mozzarella Cheese. …
  • Muenster Cheese. …
  • Gouda Cheese. …
  • Comté Cheese. …
  • Emmenthal Cheese. …
  • Parmesan Cheese.

Also question is, What cheese tastes most like cheddar?

1) Cantal (the cousin of Cheddar cheese)

(Video) MY FAVORITE VEGAN CHEESE RECIPE (dairy, nut and soy free!)

Out of all the cheeses on this list, Cantal is probably the most like Cheddar. Real cheddar. Farmhouse cheddar, aged cheddar—the good cheddar.

Besides Is there another name for white cheddar cheese? Colby Cheese

The first white cheddar substitute that most fall in love with is Colby cheese. Colby, otherwise known as Colby Swiss Cheddar, mimics the characteristics of white cheddar closely despite being a yellow cheese. It is slightly softer and a little less intense.

Also, Can I use Velveeta instead of cheddar cheese?

That’s why Velveeta cheese is used as a dip, sauce, or as part of many recipes and dishes. … Can I substitute Velveeta cheese? Sure you can. This cheese has its replacements including Swiss cheese, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Extra Sharp Cheddar cheese, Pepper Jack, American cheese, Cheez Whiz, and Eden cheese.

Can I use Monterey Jack instead of cheddar?

Cheddar cheese will melt like Monterey jack cheese can; however, Cheddar’s flavor is much creamier and more pronounced than Monterey jack. Typically, cheddar cheese is best when it is in baked recipes that call for Monterey jack cheese.

(Video) Healthier Alternative to Boxed Mac & Cheese!!!


15 Related Questions and Answers Found

Is pepper jack cheese the same as Colby-Jack?

It is noted for its mild flavor and slight sweetness. In addition to being eaten by itself, it is frequently marbled with Colby to produce Colby-Jack, or with yellow cheddar to produce cheddar-Jack. Pepper Jack is a version flavored with chili peppers and herbs.

Is Pepper Jack the same as Monterey Jack?

Monterey Jack, sometimes shortened to Jack, is a Californian white, semi-hard cheese made using cow’s milk. It is noted for its mild flavor and slight sweetness. … Pepper Jack is a version flavored with chili peppers and herbs.

What cheese is closest to white cheddar?

The best white Cheddar substitutes

(Video) American Cheese Or Cheddar
  • Yellow Cheddar.
  • Colby cheese.
  • Double Gloucester cheese.
  • Brick cheese.
  • Tillamook cheese.
  • Cantal.
  • Edam.
  • Gouda.

Can I use mozzarella instead of cheddar?

Cheddar can be substituted for mozzarella and will still create an edible result. Depending on how big a part cheese plays in the recipe, it may end up tasting very different from what you expect, in terms of flavor and texture.

Can I use tasty cheese instead of cheddar?

Not the same product. Cheddar is a very tasty cheese used for cold and grilled sandwiches, homemade mac and cheese, and many other real food preparations. It has the attributes of both flavor and texture, and is made in a traditional natural process in many places.

Which cheese is best for health?

Here are 9 of the healthiest types of cheese.

  1. Mozzarella. Mozzarella is a soft, white cheese with high moisture content. …
  2. Blue Cheese. Blue cheese is made from cow, goat, or sheep’s milk that has been cured with cultures from the mold Penicillium ( 10 ). …
  3. Feta. Share on Pinterest. …
  4. Cottage Cheese. …
  5. Ricotta. …
  6. Parmesan. …
  7. Swiss. …
  8. Cheddar.

What is the best brand of cheddar cheese?

The best cheddar cheeses to buy

  1. Kerrygold Aged Cheddar. …
  2. Cabot Vermont Sharp Cheddar. …
  3. Cabot Sharp Light Natural Vermont Cheddar, 50% Reduced Fat. …
  4. 365 Everyday Value Organic Sharp Cheddar. …
  5. Tillamook Medium Cheddar. …
  6. Organic Valley Raw Sharp Cheddar. …
  7. Sargento Medium Cheddar Slices. …
  8. Great Value Medium Cheddar.

Is white cheddar cheese healthy?

Cheddar cheese is a good source of calcium—one of the most important nutrients for promoting bone health. People who maintain a diet rich in calcium are less likely to develop osteoporosis. The vitamin K in cheddar cheese also plays a valuable role in promoting bone health. Healthy teeth.

Why you should never eat Velveeta?

Number two, American cheese, which is also processed, has to be refrigerated, Velveeta doesn’t case closed. … Number three, If you’re lactose intolerant then Velveeta isn’t for you, it has even more lactose than real cheese at a whopping, 9.3% over cheddar having only 2.1%.

Is Velveeta a cheddar cheese?

We also reached out via email and a spokesperson said, “Velveeta contains cheddar cheese made specifically to deliver the unmistakable melt and creaminess that consumers know and love. … According to the Velveeta label, it is “pasteurized recipe cheese product.”

(Video) 3 Ingredient Mac and Cheese (Delicious)

Is Cheez Whiz and Velveeta the same?

Velveeta is «pasteurized processed cheese food.» Velveeta is not real cheese. In layman’s terms, Cheez Whiz is made of whey (a protein byproduct of milk), oil, sodium-heavy flavorings, and a concoction of ingredients that help make it bright yellow and shelf-stable. …

Can I use Monterey Jack instead of Parmesan cheese?

Monterey Jack is a semi-hard cheese, good for melting. Dry Jack is a variation that ages for at least 10 months and up to four years; during that time the cheese wheels get brittle, producing a crumbly cheese that has a texture similar to Parmesan but with the rich, earthy flavor of Monterey Jack.

What is Monterey Jack cheese good for?

Because it has mellow flavor, a high moisture content, and good melting properties, Monterey Jack is great for making toasted sandwiches; topping soups or vegetable tarts; adding richness to baked pasta dishes; and folding into biscuit, scone, and bread dough.

Which Mexican cheese melts best?

Similar to unaged Montery Jack, Oaxaca cheese is a white, semihard cheese that’s excellent for melting. Try mild queso oaxaca for this awesome cheese-topped guacamole.

Why is Jack in cheese names?

Named after its creator, David Jacks, a cheesemaker near Monterey, California. Jack cheese is made from pasteurized whole, partly skimmed or skimmed cow’s milk. … Aged jack is often used as a grating cheese and can be found in specialty cheese shops.

Is Pepper Jack a good melting cheese?

Spicy, delicate and buttery, Pepper Jack Cheese is semi-soft and open textured with a slightly tart flavor. Pepper Jack is great in the home kitchen and restaurant alike. It has a high moisture content and melts easily. … Blue cheeses and soft cheeses such as Brie and Camembert also melt well if you remove the rind.

What’s the healthiest cheese?

Here are 9 of the healthiest types of cheese.

(Video) 6 Cheeses You Should Never Put In Your Body

  1. Mozzarella. Mozzarella is a soft, white cheese with high moisture content. …
  2. Blue Cheese. Blue cheese is made from cow, goat, or sheep’s milk that has been cured with cultures from the mold Penicillium ( 10 ). …
  3. Feta. Share on Pinterest. …
  4. Cottage Cheese. …
  5. Ricotta. …
  6. Parmesan. …
  7. Swiss. …
  8. Cheddar.

Editors. 27 – Last Updated. 12 days ago – Authors. 4


What can I substitute cheddar cheese with? ›

Easy Ways to Substitute for Cheddar Cheese
  • American Cheese.
  • Colby Cheese. Colby cheese is a great cheddar substitute in mac and cheese, on burgers, in cheese dips, and on sandwiches. ...
  • Swiss Cheese. ...
  • Blue Cheese. ...
  • Gouda Cheese. ...
  • Parmesan Cheese. ...
  • Brick Cheese. ...
  • Mozzarella Cheese.
22 Apr 2022

What is a healthy substitute for cheddar cheese? ›

The most common natural cheese substitute is a product called nutritional yeast, a favorite in the vegan community thanks to its nutty, cheesy flavor. Nutritional yeast can be a good substitute for cheese because it's rich in protein and B-vitamins while being low in fat and sodium.

What is Cheddar cheese the same as? ›

Cheddar is a hard English cheese while American cheese is a smooth and creamy processed cheese. Cheddar has more flavor while American cheese, being artificially processed rather than aged naturally, is less expensive.

Can mozzarella cheese be substituted for cheddar cheese? ›

Mozzarella isn't the same as other cheese varieties described in our list. But, due to its melting nature and mild flavor, it can substitute cheddar cheese very well. There are slight variations in the taste as mozzarella isn't as salty or sharp as cheddar.

Is cheddar the same as mozzarella? ›

Compared to mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese has a yellowish colour and harder texture. This type of cheese is made using cow milk and it is the most commercially produced variant. Various countries across the globe produce cheddar cheese including the US, New Zealand, Australia, Netherlands, Belgium, and Sweden.

Is cheddar cheese same as Parmesan? ›

Cheddar cheese is a hard English cheese, while Parmesan is a hard Italian cheese. Parmesan has a rich flavor and less aging time while Cheddar cheese is less expensive and has fewer calories.

What is a non dairy substitute for cheddar cheese? ›

Almond cheese has a nutty, rich flavor that makes plenty of healthy cheese alternatives, from soft ricotta and cream cheese to hard vegan cheddar blocks. Make soft almond cheese at home by soaking the nuts and blending in a high-powered blender with your favorite herbs, spices, nutritional yeast, and lemon juice.

Which is better for you cheddar or mozzarella? ›

Mozzarella is relatively low in fat and calories. This makes it a healthier cheese option compared to others. Mozzarella contains probiotics such as the bacteria Lactobacillus casei and Lactobacillus fermentum.

Is white cheese the same as cheddar? ›

There is no difference in taste when comparing white and yellow cheddar of the same age* – the only difference is the annatto food coloring.

Is feta cheese like cheddar? ›

What's more, feta is lower in fat and calories than aged cheeses like cheddar or parmesan. One ounce (28 grams) of cheddar or parmesan contains more than 110 calories and 7 grams of fat, while 1 ounce of feta has only 74 calories and 6 grams of fat (2, 3, 4).

Can I use Colby Jack cheese instead of cheddar? ›

While Colby might not be the most flavorful cheese, it makes up for that in smoothness and easy melting. Substitute Colby for Cheddar or other cheeses in recipes like these.

Can I use Velveeta instead of cheddar cheese? ›

You can substitute cheddar in a 1:1 ratio for Velveeta, though with sharp or flavorful cheddars, you may want to reduce the amount of cheese you add. What is this? Cheddar is much thicker than either Velveeta or American cheese and so may not be the best choice for sauces and dips.

Is Havarti cheese like cheddar? ›

Due to the mild and subtle notes, Havarti boasts many of the traits seen in other semi-hard cheeses that pride themselves on being similarly versatile. Another cheese known for its wide range of uses, Cheddar, is closely related to Havarti, especially when aged.

Is cheddar same as Monterey Jack? ›

Monterey jack vs cheddar

Cheddar cheese has a slightly more creamy texture than that of the Monterey Jack. What is this? In comparison, Cheddar cheese has a sharper flavour because it ages more. All in all, I would say that Cheddar cheese is more creamy and complex in terms of flavour.

Why do they call it cheddar cheese? ›

A town in south-western England gave cheddar cheese its name; the act of piling slabs of curd on top of each other to make a long-lasting cheese is known as “cheddaring”. However, a cheddar, even when it is not cheddared or from the town of Cheddar, can still be considered a cheddar.

What is cheddar cheese made of? ›

Cheddar cheese, the most widely purchased and eaten cheese globally, is always made from cow's milk. It is a hard cheese with a slightly crumbly texture if properly cured, and if it is too young, the texture is smooth. It gets a sharper taste as it matures, over a period of time between 9 to 24 months.

Is cheddar and butter same? ›

Butter and cheese are made of the same ingredient: milk. The main difference, however, is that butter consists of mostly milk fat. In fact, according to FDA standards, it must contain no less than 80% milk fat. Cheese on the other hand, consists mainly of milk protein.

What is difference between process cheese and cheddar cheese? ›

The major differences between processed and natural cheese are that natural cheeses have the whey (watery part of the milk) pressed out of them, while processed cheese does not; and processed cheese has a longer shelf life as compared to natural cheese.

Is Parmesan cheese better than cheddar? ›

For a quick recap of significant nutrients and differences in cheddar cheese and parmesan cheese: Both parmesan cheese and cheddar cheese are high in Vitamin A, calcium, calories, protein and saturated fat. Parmesan cheese has more niacin, however, cheddar cheese contains more folate.

What can I use instead of cheddar for mac and cheese? ›

Gruyere is a classic addition because it melts much like Cheddar, but has a lovely nutty flavor. Other classics include Gouda, Muenster, Parmesan, fontina, Havarti and Monterey Jack. Brie works well too, just make sure you remove the rind before mixing it in.

Is there non dairy cheddar cheese? ›

Made from plant-based ingredients, our delicious Simple Truth™ Non-Dairy Cheddar Style Shreds are the perfect vegan alternative for cheese. Try them on nachos, in macaroni and cheese or in grilled cheese sandwiches!

Which cheese is anti inflammatory? ›

Or, consider switching to Swiss cheese; one study found the probiotics in this variety could decrease inflammation.

What is the best cheese to eat if you have high cholesterol? ›

Using lower-fat cheeses – such as mozzarella, feta, cottage cheese or reduced-fat cheeses – will provide less saturated fat.

Which cheese can be eaten everyday? ›

Hard cheeses, such as Swiss, Parmesan, and cheddar, are generally great low-lactose options, Matone says. "In addition, goat milk cheese and buffalo mozzarella may contain less lactose compared with cheese made from cow's milk," she says.

What cheese is good for the heart? ›

Cottage cheese, ricotta cheese, and nonfat cheeses are generally considered healthier than many other types of cheese. This is because these cheeses often contain lower amounts of cholesterol and saturated fat.

What cheese has the highest protein? ›

Parmesan - 35.1 g

Keep in mind, although it's the highest protein cheese, you wouldn't eat as much parmesan as you would say Edam or Halloumi. Per 100g, Parmesan has 35.1g of protein, 0.0g of carbs and 28.8g of fat.

What is cheddar cheese called in America? ›

Today, American-style cheddar is often known as “block cheddar” because it is formed into large blocks that can weigh 600 pounds apiece.

Is Brie cheese like cheddar? ›

Similar in texture to Camembert, but with a higher fat content (29g per cent, 18 per cent saturated), Brie is produced from whole or semi-skimmed cow's milk. Although it is high in fat, Brie still has less fat than Cheddar or Stilton. Look out for 'light' versions of brie which will have less fat.

Can I substitute Gouda for cheddar? ›

Cheddar has a stronger flavor.

Gouda cheese has a sweet and nutty flavor, whereas cheddar cheese's flavor is less sweet, more buttery, and overall stronger. You can use Gouda and cheddar interchangeably in many cheese recipes. The flavor differences between the two are subtle but still noticeable.

Is Kraft cheese cheddar cheese? ›

Kraft Singles are an individually wrapped, processed cheese slice, with a clean and milky, creamy cheddar flavour.

Can you substitute feta for cheddar cheese? ›

What is this? Cheddar can substitute for feta on salads, burgers, and wraps. Make sure to shred it as it's not a crumbly cheese.

Does feta cheese melt? ›

Cooking: Feta melts well, turning soft, not gooey, and maintains its flavor when heated. One way to serve Feta which will blow your mind is to mix it with fresh melon of any kind. It's a life-changer.

Why do I crave cheese? ›

Cheese contains the stimulant tyramine and milk contains tryptophan — which triggers the release of the “feel-good chemical" serotonin — as well as choline, which has soothing properties, Snyder explains. Plus, much of what makes cheese so appealing is its creamy texture, which can be comforting, she adds.

What is the substitute for cheese in cooking? ›

Nutritional yeast is one the best alternatives to cheese that every vegan can keep in their back pocket - it's the perfect, no-dairy cheese that makes every meal more delicious with just a little sprinkle. A nutritional yeast cheese substitute most closely resembles Parmesan with its nutty, rich, and salty flavor.

Can I substitute Velveeta for cheddar cheese? ›

Whether you're using sharp cheddar cheese, mild, or any other type, cheddar is a good replacement for regular Velveeta. You'll also find that shredded cheddar cheese is a wonderful replacement for shredded Velveeta. Cheddar typically has an orange or yellow color, just like Velveeta, and is very versatile.

Can I substitute Swiss cheese for cheddar? ›

Swiss cheese melts beautifully, giving you a satisfying cheese pull. It also goes well with chicken and ham due to its mild flavor. With that in mind, if you're making Chicken Cordon Bleu and can't find Swiss cheese, a stringy cheese like cheddar, provolone, or mozzarella is a great substitute.

What is the closest thing to cheese? ›

Silken Tofu can substitute cheese in many recipes, replacing cottage cheese or ricotta in dips, sauces, smoothies, pies, and pasta dishes.

Is Colby just cheddar? ›

Although the flavor of Colby has many parallels with cheddar, it would be a disservice to describe it as simply a mild cheddar. Colby is a firm cheese that tastes lactic and mild, with a buttery finish. Compared to cheddar, Colby has a more open texture and a sweeter flavor.

Is Monterey Jack like cheddar? ›

It is similar in taste and texture to Colby and Cheddar. Variants of Monterey Jack known as Dry Jack (aged version) and Pepper Jack (pepper spiced) are also quite popular. Monterey Jack is available across all grocery stores and supermarkets in the United States. Consider Pinot Noir and Riesling with this cheese.


1. Vegan low fat CHEDDAR CHEESE (it slices, melts, grills AND you can freeze it!)
(Vegan Hippie)
2. How to MELT Vegan Cheese! #Shorts
(Thee Burger Dude)
3. The Best Cheeses To Improve Diabetes & Lose Weight!
(Chef Jana)
5. Why Traditional English Cheddar Is Aged In Caves | Regional Eats
(Food Insider)
6. Cheddar cheese and my blood sugar. How does it affect my glucose levels? #bloodsugar #cheese
(Insulin Resistant 1 )
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Msgr. Refugio Daniel

Last Updated: 10/17/2022

Views: 6255

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Msgr. Refugio Daniel

Birthday: 1999-09-15

Address: 8416 Beatty Center, Derekfort, VA 72092-0500

Phone: +6838967160603

Job: Mining Executive

Hobby: Woodworking, Knitting, Fishing, Coffee roasting, Kayaking, Horseback riding, Kite flying

Introduction: My name is Msgr. Refugio Daniel, I am a fine, precious, encouraging, calm, glamorous, vivacious, friendly person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.